Available Mondays

PASTA

Pasta Monday · All Day

Every Monday Tonio's goes full Italian. Rich sauces, fresh pasta and Keys-inspired twists on the classics.

Side salads available as an add-on.

Chicken Alfredo

Shrimp Alfredo

Lobster Fra Diavolo

Lobster Ravioli In a blush sauce

Linguini & Homemade Meatballs

Linguini & Sausage In homemade marinara

Linguini Bolognese In a homemade meat sauce

Manicotti Stuffed with ricotta

Chicken Francaise Egg battered chicken in lemon white wine sauce

Penne Vodka In a homemade vodka sauce

Menu selections may vary. Ask your server about tonight's pasta specials.

Available Tuesdays

CRABFEAST

Crabfeast Tuesday · All Day

Tuesday is all about the crab. From stone crab to snow crab, crab cakes to crab-stuffed anything — if it's crab, it's on the table Tuesday night at Tonio's.

Stone Crab Claws Market Price Chilled or warm, served with mustard sauce

Snow Crab Legs Market Price Steamed with drawn butter and lemon

Crab Cakes Jumbo lump blue crab, served with remoulade

Crab-Stuffed Shrimp Jumbo shrimp stuffed with seasoned crab meat, broiled

Crab-Stuffed Grouper Fresh grouper fillet stuffed with blue crab and herbs

Crab & Corn Chowder Creamy Keys-style chowder with sweet corn and blue crab

Soft Shell Crab Lightly fried, served over greens with remoulade

Crab Mac & Cheese House mac topped with lump blue crab and Old Bay breadcrumbs

Crab availability is subject to season and daily catch. Stone crab is available mid-October through mid-May.

Available Wednesdays

WING

Wing Wednesday · 3–10 PM

Hump day calls for wings. Crispy, saucy and piled high — Wednesday nights at Tonio's are all about the wings. Pick your sauce, grab a cold beer and settle in.

Classic Buffalo Hot sauce and butter — the original, done right

Garlic Parmesan Roasted garlic, real parm, fresh herbs

Honey Old Bay A Florida Keys original — sweet heat with a coastal kick

Mango Habanero Tropical sweet and blazing hot — island style

BBQ Slow-smoked flavor, tangy house BBQ sauce

Naked (Dry Rub) House-seasoned, crispy fried with no sauce — Tonio's dry rub

Tenders Hand-breaded chicken tenders, choice of dipping sauce

Loaded Wing Platter Your choice of two sauces with celery, carrots and house ranch

Wing sauces and specials may vary weekly. Ask your server about Wednesday's featured sauce and deals.

Every Thursday

SUSHI

Sushi Thursday · All Day

Every Thursday, Tonio's rolls out fresh sushi, Keys-inspired combinations and signature favorites. The perfect way to finish out the week.

California Roll Crab, cucumber and avocado

Shrimp Tempura Roll Fried shrimp, cucumber and avocado

Kani Salad Shredded crabmeat, cucumber and roe tossed in a spicy dressing

Salmon Roll Salmon, cucumber and avocado

Spicy Tuna Roll Spicy tuna and avocado

San Diego Roll Crab, cucumber and avocado topped with tuna

Lover's Roll Steamed shrimp, raw salmon and avocado topped with spicy mayo and eel sauce

Spider Roll Fried soft-shell crab, cucumber and avocado

Pokey Bowl Spicy tuna, seaweed salad and kani salad served over sushi rice

Maryland Crab Roll Crab, asparagus and avocado

Philadelphia Roll Salmon, avocado and cream cheese

Veggie Roll Avocado, cucumber, asparagus and cream cheese

Summerland Roll Fried lobster, cream cheese, avocado, kani salad and red tobiko topped with tempura flakes

Menu selections and availability may change based on the freshest ingredients available.

Special Nights

PASTA

CRABFEAST

WING

SUSHI